APSA Merit Pay Guidelines
Merit increase allocation decisions should be based on objective performance-related criteria as much as possible; however, subjective judgments will have to be made. Merit increases should not be used for equity or market adjustments. The following are steps you may follow to enhance consistency:
Consider each employee's performance over the past year based on unit-designated criteria (made known to the employee), including:
- Results achieved.
- Behaviors that relate to organizational success (e.g., teamwork, creativity, initiative, innovation. See Performance Development Program form for others).
- Overall productivity and work quality.
Your conclusions about performance should have previously been discussed with employees through the appraisal process or thereafter. Summarizing key performance results may be useful in merit pay discussions with unit administrators and employees.
Based on performance ratings, construct a merit allocation guideline for the different performance levels. Performance levels include 1) Meet Expectations; 2) Exceeds Expectations; 3) Developing; or 4) Does Not Meet Expectations. See the HR Performance Excellence site for more information on performance evaluations.
Merit allocation guidelines may be structured in a number of ways, including:
- Using percentages.
- Using flat dollar amounts.
- Recognizing performance/achievements of work teams.
Determine merit pay allocations. It is important to understand that, regardless of the approach used, actual allocations will not be based on a fixed formula, since numerous factors will affect merit allocations, including:
- The spread of performance levels in a unit.
- Whether some exceptional employees substantially exceeded performance expectations.
- The number of employees in the unit.
The following should not be considered in determining merit pay:
- Eligibility for APL (Automatic Progression Level) increases.
- Age, ethnicity, gender, disability, etc.
Communicate with employees about the specific reasons for their merit allocations. Topics to discuss may include the performance criteria you used, key performance results and any merit guideline you used. This dialog should occur before distribution of the Salary Notification letter (and certainly before it is received in the employee's paycheck). Both the APSA and the University place a high value on thorough communication about merit awards.